Freshmen making big impact on Greene County girls' basketball rosters
/White River valley freshman maddy settles leads her team in scoring at 16.7 points per game coming into this week’s games. (Photo by Renee Wiggington with Moments in Photos)
It’s not unusual for Greene County basketball coaches to have freshmen on their varsity rosters. Some first-year players even find themselves in the starting lineup.
But a recent trend for county schools is more noticeable this season on the girls’ side. All county schools have freshmen on the varsity roster, some are filled with more than half first-year players, and others have freshmen contributing in significant ways.
Without the young players, some schools wouldn’t be able to field a team.
One such school is Shakamak High School. Coach Brock Dowell credits his freshmen for stepping up and making sure the school has a team. Of his 11 varsity players, eight are freshmen.
“A big reason why so many are on the roster is that without them, we would not have a team this year. There are a lot of athletes at Shakamak and other schools who would rather do anything other than play basketball,” Dowell explained.
Dowell and White River Valley Coach April Settles share they’ve heard from players about the length of the basketball season being a deterrent to playing.
“Basketball season is arguably the longest season of all the high school sports, and it’s hard. It’s been a discussion that a lot of coaches have had, and it’s one of those situations that may never go away,” Dowell said.
“As for our team, we will continue to roll with the girls who want to play and want to work hard and do our best to improve every day.”
Small high school enrollments and athletes participating in fall sports that do well in the state tournament also present possible issues.
“I have expressed my concerns that I think the length of the basketball season is too long in high school. For example, my soccer players ended their season on a Saturday and then basketball practice was supposed to start that Monday and continues into February,” Settles explained. “Kids need a break, both mentally and physically when they transition from one sport to another.
“For soccer, our numbers are strong as the season starts in August, and sectional starts the first part of October. For basketball, the season also hits over a time when families want to be together (Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year’s). Players are also asked to play a single sport for the entire year now. Volleyball runs throughout the winter and spring and even softball has indoor tourneys throughout the winter. So many athletes are having to move to only playing a single sport so that they can keep up.”
Bloomfield Coach Siera Babcock, who is in her fifth season leading the Lady Cardinals, says low numbers contributes to the county’s freshmen-heavy rosters.
“In Greene County we are struggling with numbers across the board,” Babcock said. “When a player comes in regardless of age and can contribute, they earn time.”
Freshman ellie figg leads Bloomfield in scoring at 13 points per game coming into this week’s games. (Photo by three strands photography)
The breakdown of freshmen per varsity rosters for each county team (statistics through Nov. 15):
• White River Valley — four total, and all are getting playing time. Two, Maddy Settles and Lilly-Ann Livingston, have started every game. Settles leads the Lady Wolverines in scoring at 16.7 points per game, and she averages five rebounds, five steals, 1.7 blocks, and 3.3 assists per game. Livingston averages 6.3 points.
• Bloomfield — three total, and all three are getting playing time. Two, Ellie Figg and KaLyn Stephens, are starters. Figg leads the Lady Cardinals in scoring at 13 points per game and she adds 7 rebounds. Babcock says Stephens is “playing amazing defense” and is averaging 3.5 assists per game. The other freshman, Madilyn Patton is averaging 3.5 rebounds.
• Shakamak — eight total (of the 11 players on the roster), and all eight have played this season. Five have started at least once so far (Kaylee Calvert, Annabelle Ehle, Jacelynn Coffey, Emerson Estey, and Madeline Jaco). Calvert averages 8.7 points per game (with a high of 21), and Ehle is averaging 2.5 per game (high of 10).
• Eastern Greene — two total (Ava Holtsclaw and Reagan Kelley), and they are splitting time with the junior varsity. Both are playing five to 10 minutes per varsity game, and Holtsclaw is averaging 2 points per game.
• Linton — Coach Garrett Vandeventer said his freshmen are spending most of their time on the junior varsity, though he tries to work them into varsity situations when possible.
Babcock said if a player can play, it doesn’t matter if she is a freshman or senior.
“They have to learn by trial and error. We’ve always done that. For example, Lola Myers is now a senior, she played as a freshman and has come a long way. It is baptism by fire in some instances. But they learn, grow, and develop,” Babcock explained. “This has always happened. If a freshman can contribute and add great value within a team of upperclassmen, they typically get that opportunity.”
She said a willingness to learn and compete are also key for freshmen to get playing time.
“If a player comes in and gives 100 percent effort, attempts to correct mistakes, and helps the team, it doesn't matter the age,” Babcock shared.
“Those players earn varsity time. We’re thankful we have girls of all ages that can mesh well together and contribute.”
Eastern Greene Coach Nathan Martindale said it can be tough jumping from an eighth grader to the varsity level as a freshman.
“The speed of the game is different at each level. From middle school to JV is a jump, so middle school to varsity is an even bigger jump,” Martindale explained.
“They have to play through mistakes of the game because basketball is an imperfect sport.”
Dowell, who is in his third season as head coach at Shakamak, said his goal is to figure out a freshmen’s strengths and weaknesses, and put them in the best possible position to be successful. He said some are ready for varsity play because they’ve been spotlight players for a while, and others aren’t.
“The one thing I tell them is that if they practice hard, play hard, have a good attitude and are great teammates, they will get opportunities on the court,” Dowell explained.
Dowell is trying to build a solid foundation of fundamentals in the lower grades, so the girls are better prepared when they enter high school.
“Every day has been a learning experience for me as a coach, and I can’t say enough good things about our group because they have shown an eagerness to learn and want to be coached and taught,” Dowell said.
Settles has the lowest total number of players on her varsity roster than any school in Greene County. The freshmen also vary in abilities.
“For Maddy, she’s been playing at a high level for many years. She started playing up (with older girls) when she was in kindergarten. While she plays three sports, basketball is her favorite and best sport,” Settles said, adding that her daughter played up this past summer with the incoming seniors at DistinXion in a few tourneys.
DistinXion is an AAU faith-based program that was started by Luke Zeller when he was a player at Notre Dame. Zeller still runs it and Settles coaches a team with him. It was originally based in Washington and is now in Bloomington.
The fifth-year WRV coach said it’s important to remain patient when working with freshmen.
“Yes, the freshmen do make freshmen mistakes, but they are open-minded and willing to learn. We push them in practice and have even brought in practice players to assist with their development and to get them ready to play a physical style of game,” Settles explained.
Dowell has enjoyed working with the freshmen and hopes he has eight every season. He believes that will make his overall program stronger.
“Personally, I hope every year we could get eight freshmen to come in and immediately compete to play heavy minutes,” Dowell said. “That is what we’re trying to build up in our younger grades. Athletes who don’t want to specialize, but play every sport they can because they are that competitive. And they don’t want to let an opportunity to represent our school slip by.”